WELCOME TO THE SMILIST Shelter Island
Better oral health starts here.
The Smilist Dental in Shelter Island, NY includes a team of highly skilled Dentists and Dental Professionals committed to meeting your dental needs under one roof.
- Comprehensive Dentistry
- Accepting New Patients
- Direct Insurance Billing
- Evening Appointments
- Smilist Guarantee
- 4.9 Stars on Google
- Comprehensive Dentistry
- Accepting New Patients
- Direct Insurance Billing
- Evening Appointments
- Smilist Guarantee
- 4.9 Stars on Google
OR CALL 631-749-0539

THE SMILIST DIFFERENCE
Feel amazing about your oral health with the Smilist!
Safety First
We focus on your safety with health screens, enhanced PPE, no contact check-ins, and more.
Insurance accepted
We’re in network with most major insurers like Aetna, Cigna, Delta Dental, and more!
Highly-Rated Dentists
Our dentists are well reviewed on top directories and Google.
Modern Office
We have a beautiful modern office with advanced technology.
Book an Appointment or Check Insurance
Let’s get started with a few details…

A dental experience built around quality and convenience.
- Comprehensive dentistry
- Direct insurance billing
- Short notice visits available
- 24/7 online bookings
- Open evenings
- Online registration and payments
- Advanced technology
- Competitive pricing
- Comprehensive dentistry
- Direct insurance billing
- Short notice visits available
- 24/7 online bookings
- Competitive pricing
- Open evenings
- Online registration and payments
- Advanced technology
OR CALL 631-749-0539
Insurance, pricing, and membership plans that will make you smile!
Most Insurances Accepted In Shelter Island, NY
Most dental insurance plans are accepted at The Smilist located in Shelter Island, NY. As a courtesy to our patients, we submit insurance claims on your behalf. Our highly-trained team will be able to help you with your benefits and estimates to give you an idea of what your insurance coverage is and how much you can expect out of pocket. We also provide financing options for your out-of-pocket totals so nothing stands in the way of your treatment.
- Direct insurance billing
- Affordable out of pocket care
- Smilist One membership plan


We have a 4.9 star Google rating across over 83 reviews!
Meet Your Shelter Island Dentist

Dr. Kestler
General Dentist
Dentist Shelter Island – General & Cosmetic Dentistry
The Smilist Dental in Shelter Island, NY includes a team of highly skilled Dentists, and Dental Professionals committed to meeting your dental needs under one roof. This Suffolk County office provides an extensive amount of services such as general dentistry, teeth whitening, cosmetic dentistry, restorative dentistry, and Invisalign. We’re proud to bring high-quality family dentistry for adults and children to the Shelter Island, Shelter Island Heights, Dering Harbor, North Haven, Ram Island, Greenport, Greenport West, East Marion, Orient, Noyack, and Sag Harbor region. Thank you for choosing The Smilist as your Shelter Island, NY dentist.
Our Dental Services In Shelter Island, NY
- General Dentistry
- Family Dentistry
- Restorative Dentistry
- Invisalign®
- Emergency Dentistry
- Teeth Whitening
- Periodontics
- Teeth Pain Relief
- Cosmetic Dentistry
- Dental Implants
- Dental Crowns
- Tooth Fillings
- General Dentistry
- Family Dentistry
- Restorative Dentistry
- Invisalign®
- Emergency Dentistry
- Teeth Whitening
- Periodontics
- Teeth Pain Relief
- Cosmetic Dentistry
- Dental Implants
- Dental Crowns
- Tooth Fillings
We’ve carefully crafted a patient experience that we know you will love!
Special Offers
Enjoy one of our current, limited time offers!
Dental Services
Full range of general, cosmetic, restorative, and surgical dentistry.
Patient Experience
We’ve crafted a dental experience unlike any other!
Membership
Dental membership plans starting at $25/m.
We’re Accepting New Patients!
Contact Us
The Smilist Dental – Shelter Island, NY
51A North Ferry Road
Shelter Island, NY 11964
t: 631-749-0539
Hours of Operation
Mon: Closed
Tues: 8am – 2pm
Wed: 8am – 2pm
Thurs: 12pm – 6pm
Fri: Closed
Ask us a question or have us check your insurance coverage
Curious if you are covered under your current insurance plan? Have a question? Fill out the form below and one of our team members will get back to you as soon as possible.
The Smilist Dental – Shelter Island, NY Dental Services

General Dentistry in Shelter Island, NY
Our Shelter Island, NY dental office is a full dental service facility that performs routine dental treatments like dental exams, teeth cleanings and digital x-rays to help you keep your mouth healthy. General dentistry includes restorative dental treatments for your teeth, from tooth fillings and crowns to bridges and dentures. Our well-experienced and skilled dentists and dental specialists truly care about your oral health and will do their best ensure you get the highest patient care available. This includes educating our patients the way to properly care and protect your teeth and gums from damage. We even offer emergency appointments when accidents happens.

Cosmetic Dentistry in Shelter Island, NY
If you feel like you want to improve the look of your smile, cosmetic dentistry may be the right answer for you. Our Shelter Island, NY dental office offers cosmetic dentistry treatments to help you with getting the perfect smile you’ve always wanted. Cosmetic dentistry includes teeth whitening to assist in removing any stains which have developed from foods and drinks. We additionally offer composite or porcelain veneers that change the form and color of your teeth. Veneers are thin restorations that are modified to accommodate your teeth and afterward positioned over them, giving you a complete new smile.

Invisalign® in Shelter Island, NY
Unlike traditional metal braces, Invisalign® is a clear and removable alternative to help achieve a straight smile. They’re an excellent, non-invasive type of braces that our Shelter Island, NY dental office offers with no metal brackets needed! The Invisalign® process involves a custom-fit, clear plastic aligner that you wear to gradually shift your teeth into the desired position. Since the aligners are clear, they are virtually invisible to others who see you smile. While the process is subtle, Invisalign® aligners ensures that your daily life will not be affected by them. Invisalign® is a great choice for patients with crowding, minor spaces between the teeth, overbites, and underbites. They also work well for patients of all ages.

Emergency Dentistry in Shelter Island, NY
It’s understandable that emergencies can happen to any of us at any time. If you have a dental emergency, our Shelter Island, NY dental office is here to assist. Whether you’ve experienced an accident or are suffering from aching tooth pain, we offer emergency appointments so that you can get back to your life. Dental mishaps may happen due to a sports injury, while eating, or even a fall, or even without any cause at all. Do not hesitate to give our office a call so we can assist you as soon as possible. If your emergency or pain is severe or happens after business hours, you should seek immediate attention from an emergency room.

Teeth Whitening in Shelter Island, NY
Because our teeth naturally lose its white brilliance it once had, teeth whitening is a great option to restore its look. Foods and drinks like tomatoes, coffee and wine stain your teeth after a while. For that reason, we offer teeth whitening options that can help lift those stains and make your teeth look brighter, reviving your bright smile. Our Shelter Island, NY dental office offers solutions to assist in whitening your teeth, including take-home teeth whitening kits and in-office teeth whitening treatments. Take-home teeth whitening kits are an excellent choice as they gradually brighten your smile and are very affordable. In-office teeth whitening offers the best results and work immediately after one visit. If you’re interested in teeth whitening and would really like to learn more, please don’t hesitate to call us. We will be glad to help you with deciding the best option to achieve a whiter smile.